UPDATE: 6/26/07
Alright, since Friday is the hotly anticipated debut of the iPhone, I thought it would be poetic to resurrect this post from six months ago.
As the Mac elitists salivate over what could be their next very expensive gadget I will watch and wait. I’m thinking the touch controls might not be as intuitive as described. I’m thinking people will get irritated by all the fingerprints, smudges, and makeup residue (for the ladies of course) all over their pretty machine. I’m thinking people will soon realize that surfing the web from a phone is not “fun” but it is tiresome and really only useful in a pinch. I’m thinking that smart phone users won’t really find the usefulness of the device to be any greater than what they are used to.
Then again, anyone crazy enough to drop five or six hundred dollars on a phone without a thought would be in denial about it. Not only that, but it is the first generation and everyone knows that its best not to buy a first generation electronic device (especially with Apple since they tend to make their own products obsolete very quickly). Nevertheless, Mac fanatics will stand behind their product whether they truly love it or not.
Huh, here is a first review…
——————————————————————–
Original Post:
Alright. I want to make this rant really quick. Yesterday was the MACWORLD conference where Steve Jobs introduces all the new products that Mac will be introducing this year. The media is going nuts over the new iPhone and iTV (there was even a website giving minute by minute updates on the conference). The hype is so hot that Mac shares went up like 8% in one day. I say so what.
In 2001, when Mac introduced the 1st Gen iPod to the world I had the same reaction. I already had an mp3 player. It was made by a company called iRiver. Comparing apples to apples my iRiver beat out the iPod in every category except one…looks. A couple years later I upgraded to a new hard drive based iRiver, the H300. My H300 is awesome. It plays many formats of music, shows pictures and videos, has a built in mic and line inputs for recording, has FM radio, text reader and more. Again, my H300 easily beat out the iPod for features (but not looks). Then Mac released the photo iPod and then the video iPod and the features still don’t match what my now discontinued H300 can do. So what’s my point?
Mac is not as revolutionary as they claim to be. What makes them dominate is that their products look nice, have good interfaces, and they use incredibly clever marketing tactics. Mac people will counter and say, but the iPod is so popular because of iTunes. Well, I read some stats about iTunes. It was something about if you take the total number of songs and divide it by the number of iPods it averages out to like five songs sold per iPod. So that couldn’t possibly be the selling point. Additionally, the fact that Mac uses proprietary DRM technology (via AAC files) will come to haunt them later on (that is a discussion for another day).
Well this post isn’t about the iPod. It’s about the two new “revolutionary” products Mac has now developed. Let’s start with the iTV. This is a set-top box that allows you to view photos, movies and music that are hosted on your computer on your TV. You also have the ability to pull down content directly off of the Mac websites. The iTV has a built in 40 GB hard drive and integrated 802.11 wireless capabilities. I say SO WHAT!!
I have had my Series 2 TiVo now for 2.5 years. TiVo in general has been around much longer. My TiVo can do all this and more!! I can view my pictures and music, look at weather, buy movie tickets, download podcasts, play games, check email, get exclusive content, transfer video to/from my PC, all that the iTV has to offer. PLUS ITS A TIVO TOO!! I can record TV. Can you do that iTV? If I need to see video that my TiVo can’t handle, I simply hook my laptop up to the TV and Viola!! Additionally, if you happen to have a modded Xbox all these features are also at your finger tips. My point is that the concept of iTV is nothing new to the informed.
Now on to the iPhone. I gotta admit, at first this thing sounded awesome. Actually, the look and user interface (UI) do sound really cool. I am intrigued by the newly developed “multi-touch” technology that the touch screen uses. Anyways, this thing does it all. It’s like an iPod, PDA, web browser, and phone all in one. It can do the music, photos and video. It can control your email and calendar. It’s a cell phone. It has a built in web browser that can surf all pages, not just mobile web pages. It can piggy-back onto Wifi networks. There will be two models released. One with 4 GB of flash memory ($500) and one with 8 GB of flash memory ($600). Again, SO WHAT!!
My Moto Razr plays songs, takes pictures, downloads video, has a calendar, can surf the web, has built in GPS and navigation, can check email, etc. Take a step up to a Treo, Moto Q, or other equivalent smart phone. These all have the same features as the iPhone. So why is the iPhone so “revolutionary”? Jobs claimed that this will replace the need for multiple devices being carried around at the same time. Really Steve? Do you honestly think that somebody who is used to carrying around your 80 GB video iPod will be satisfied with a device that only holds 8 GB? I hardly think so. I don’t always need my mp3 player. I don’t always need my email. Sometimes I just want my phone. Sometimes I just want my iRiver. I like my devices separate.
On top of that, Mac made a critical mistake by signing an exclusive partnership with Cingular Wireless to be the provider. I believe that according to consumer reports Cingular is generally regarded as the countries worst wireless provider. Additionally, Cingular’s broadband network, EDGE, maxes out download speeds at 80k which pales in comparison to Verizon’s EVDO service (EDGE does have the best nationwide coverage at this point). So if you are planning on visiting graphics rich web pages, you better hope that you are in range of a Wifi network.
I don’t mean to poop on Mac (yes I do) but I just don’t see what the big deal is. Discuss away…
PS. I guess this wasn’t a quick rant…